Review-Steps Ablation Test

#	Session ID	Started	Ended	Tools	Rejected	Prompts	Plans	Reports	Turns	In Tokens	Out Tokens	Cost	Duration
1	3aaf5d04-1b8	2026-03-22T10:59:49Z	2026-03-22T11:00:37Z	16	0	2	0	0	9	9	2,092	$0.1300	48.3s

Session ID

Started

Ended

Tools

Rejected

Prompts

Plans

Reports

Turns

In Tokens

Out Tokens

Cost

Duration

3aaf5d04-1b8

2026-03-22T10:59:49Z

2026-03-22T11:00:37Z

2,092

$0.1300

48.3s

Session Details

Session 1: 3aaf5d04-1b8

tools 16rejected 0prompts 2plans 0agent reports 0turns 9in tokens 9out tokens 2,092cache read 91,149cost $0.1300duration 48.3sapi time 47.8s

started 2026-03-22T10:59:49Z

#	Time	Type	Detail show 16 ok results
1	+0.0s [+0.0s]	user_prompt	user_prompt: Review the document `draft.md` following the review-steps process. Complete the…Review the document `draft.md` following the review-steps process. Complete these stages, applying corrections directly to the file: 1. Read and understand — identify the document's function, audience, and goal 2. Language and consistency — fix spelling, grammar, punctuation; ensure consistent terminology and patterns 3. Conceptual clarity — fix incomplete sentences, unclear phrasing; expand acronyms on first use Apply all corrections directly to `draft.md` and save the result.▴
2	+0.0s [+0.0s]	user_prompt	user_prompt: Review the document `draft.md` following the review-steps process. Complete the…Review the document `draft.md` following the review-steps process. Complete these stages, applying corrections directly to the file: 1. Read and understand — identify the document's function, audience, and goal 2. Language and consistency — fix spelling, grammar, punctuation; ensure consistent terminology and patterns 3. Conceptual clarity — fix incomplete sentences, unclear phrasing; expand acronyms on first use Apply all corrections directly to `draft.md` and save the result.▴
3	+6.0s [+6.0s]	tool_call	tool_call: Read {"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md"}
4	+6.0s [+0.0s]	tool_call	tool_call: Read {"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md"}
5	+6.0s [+0.0s]	tool_result	tool_result: [ok]
6	+6.0s [+0.0s]	tool_result	tool_result: [ok]
7	+7.0s [+1.0s]	tool_call	tool_call: Bash {"command": "ls /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/audit/agent-report.sh 2>/dev/null && echo \"…{"command": "ls /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/audit/agent-report.sh 2>/dev/null && echo \"exists\" \|\| echo \"not found\"", "description": "Check if agent-report script exists"}▴
8	+7.0s [+0.0s]	tool_call	tool_call: Bash {"command": "ls /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/audit/agent-report.sh 2>/dev/null && echo \"…{"command": "ls /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/audit/agent-report.sh 2>/dev/null && echo \"exists\" \|\| echo \"not found\"", "description": "Check if agent-report script exists"}▴
9	+7.0s [+0.0s]	tool_result	tool_result: [ok]
10	+7.0s [+0.0s]	tool_result	tool_result: [ok]
11	+10.0s [+3.0s]	tool_call	tool_call: Bash {"command": "bash /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/audit/agent-report.sh \"review-session\" \…{"command": "bash /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/audit/agent-report.sh \"review-session\" \"plan_stated\" \"Review draft.md in 3 stages: read/understand, language/consistency fixes, conceptual clarity fixes. Apply corrections directly.\"", "description": "Log plan to dev record"}▴
12	+10.0s [+0.0s]	tool_call	tool_call: Bash {"command": "bash /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/audit/agent-report.sh \"review-session\" \…{"command": "bash /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/audit/agent-report.sh \"review-session\" \"plan_stated\" \"Review draft.md in 3 stages: read/understand, language/consistency fixes, conceptual clarity fixes. Apply corrections directly.\"", "description": "Log plan to dev record"}▴
13	+10.0s [+0.0s]	tool_result	tool_result: [ok]
14	+10.0s [+0.0s]	tool_result	tool_result: [ok]
15	+25.0s [+15.0s]	tool_call	tool_call: Edit {"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "Projections (also c…{"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "Projections (also called read models) materialized views that are built by processing the event stream. When a projection's schema changes, a full rebuild is required — the projection consumer resets it's offset to zero, truncates the target store, and replays every event.", "new_string": "Projections (also called read models) are materialized views that are built by processing the event stream. When a projection's schema changes, a full rebuild is required — the projection consumer resets its offset to zero, truncates the target store, and replays every event.", "replace_all": false}▴
16	+25.0s [+0.0s]	tool_call	tool_call: Edit {"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "Projections (also c…{"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "Projections (also called read models) materialized views that are built by processing the event stream. When a projection's schema changes, a full rebuild is required — the projection consumer resets it's offset to zero, truncates the target store, and replays every event.", "new_string": "Projections (also called read models) are materialized views that are built by processing the event stream. When a projection's schema changes, a full rebuild is required — the projection consumer resets its offset to zero, truncates the target store, and replays every event.", "replace_all": false}▴
17	+25.0s [+0.0s]	tool_result	tool_result: [ok]
18	+25.0s [+0.0s]	tool_result	tool_result: [ok]
19	+30.0s [+5.0s]	tool_call	tool_call: Edit {"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "On load, the system…{"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "On load, the system reads the latest snapshot and only replays events after the snapshot's sequence number, this avoids processing the complete history.", "new_string": "On load, the system reads the latest snapshot and only replays events after the snapshot's sequence number. This avoids processing the complete history.", "replace_all": false}▴
20	+30.0s [+0.0s]	tool_call	tool_call: Edit {"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "On load, the system…{"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "On load, the system reads the latest snapshot and only replays events after the snapshot's sequence number, this avoids processing the complete history.", "new_string": "On load, the system reads the latest snapshot and only replays events after the snapshot's sequence number. This avoids processing the complete history.", "replace_all": false}▴
21	+30.0s [+0.0s]	tool_result	tool_result: [ok]
22	+30.0s [+0.0s]	tool_result	tool_result: [ok]
23	+34.0s [+4.0s]	tool_call	tool_call: Edit {"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "Read-model denormal…{"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "Read-model denormalization optimizes query performance by pre-computing flattened projections. e.g. an OrderSummary projection might join data from OrderPlaced, ItemAdded and PaymentReceived events into a single document.", "new_string": "Read-model denormalization optimizes query performance by pre-computing flattened projections. For example, an OrderSummary projection might join data from OrderPlaced, ItemAdded, and PaymentReceived events into a single document.", "replace_all": false}▴
24	+34.0s [+0.0s]	tool_call	tool_call: Edit {"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "Read-model denormal…{"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "Read-model denormalization optimizes query performance by pre-computing flattened projections. e.g. an OrderSummary projection might join data from OrderPlaced, ItemAdded and PaymentReceived events into a single document.", "new_string": "Read-model denormalization optimizes query performance by pre-computing flattened projections. For example, an OrderSummary projection might join data from OrderPlaced, ItemAdded, and PaymentReceived events into a single document.", "replace_all": false}▴
25	+34.0s [+0.0s]	tool_result	tool_result: [ok]
26	+34.0s [+0.0s]	tool_result	tool_result: [ok]
27	+37.0s [+3.0s]	tool_call	tool_call: Edit {"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "Event throughput me…{"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "Event throughput metrics alone provide a incomplete picture", "new_string": "Event throughput metrics alone provide an incomplete picture", "replace_all": false}▴
28	+37.0s [+0.0s]	tool_call	tool_call: Edit {"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "Event throughput me…{"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "Event throughput metrics alone provide a incomplete picture", "new_string": "Event throughput metrics alone provide an incomplete picture", "replace_all": false}▴
29	+37.0s [+0.0s]	tool_result	tool_result: [ok]
30	+37.0s [+0.0s]	tool_result	tool_result: [ok]
31	+40.0s [+3.0s]	tool_call	tool_call: Read {"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md"}
32	+40.0s [+0.0s]	tool_call	tool_call: Read {"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md"}
33	+40.0s [+0.0s]	tool_result	tool_result: [ok]
34	+40.0s [+0.0s]	tool_result	tool_result: [ok]

Time

Type

Detail show 16 ok results

+0.0s [+0.0s]

user_prompt

user_prompt: Review the document `draft.md` following the review-steps process. Complete the…Review the document `draft.md` following the review-steps process. Complete these stages, applying corrections directly to the file: 1. **Read and understand** — identify the document's function, audience, and goal 2. **Language and consistency** — fix spelling, grammar, punctuation; ensure consistent terminology and patterns 3. **Conceptual clarity** — fix incomplete sentences, unclear phrasing; expand acronyms on first use Apply all corrections directly to `draft.md` and save the result.▴

+0.0s [+0.0s]

user_prompt

+6.0s [+6.0s]

tool_call

tool_call: Read {"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md"}

+6.0s [+0.0s]

tool_call

tool_call: Read {"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md"}

+6.0s [+0.0s]

tool_result

tool_result: [ok]

+6.0s [+0.0s]

tool_result

tool_result: [ok]

+7.0s [+1.0s]

tool_call

tool_call: Bash {"command": "ls /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/audit/agent-report.sh 2>/dev/null && echo \"…{"command": "ls /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/audit/agent-report.sh 2>/dev/null && echo \"exists\" || echo \"not found\"", "description": "Check if agent-report script exists"}▴

+7.0s [+0.0s]

tool_call

+7.0s [+0.0s]

tool_result

tool_result: [ok]

+7.0s [+0.0s]

tool_result

tool_result: [ok]

+10.0s [+3.0s]

tool_call

tool_call: Bash {"command": "bash /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/audit/agent-report.sh \"review-session\" \…{"command": "bash /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/audit/agent-report.sh \"review-session\" \"plan_stated\" \"Review draft.md in 3 stages: read/understand, language/consistency fixes, conceptual clarity fixes. Apply corrections directly.\"", "description": "Log plan to dev record"}▴

+10.0s [+0.0s]

tool_call

+10.0s [+0.0s]

tool_result

tool_result: [ok]

+10.0s [+0.0s]

tool_result

tool_result: [ok]

+25.0s [+15.0s]

tool_call

tool_call: Edit {"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "Projections (also c…{"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "Projections (also called read models) materialized views that are built by processing the event stream. When a projection's schema changes, a full rebuild is required — the projection consumer resets it's offset to zero, truncates the target store, and replays every event.", "new_string": "Projections (also called read models) are materialized views that are built by processing the event stream. When a projection's schema changes, a full rebuild is required — the projection consumer resets its offset to zero, truncates the target store, and replays every event.", "replace_all": false}▴

+25.0s [+0.0s]

tool_call

+25.0s [+0.0s]

tool_result

tool_result: [ok]

+25.0s [+0.0s]

tool_result

tool_result: [ok]

+30.0s [+5.0s]

tool_call

tool_call: Edit {"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "On load, the system…{"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "On load, the system reads the latest snapshot and only replays events after the snapshot's sequence number, this avoids processing the complete history.", "new_string": "On load, the system reads the latest snapshot and only replays events after the snapshot's sequence number. This avoids processing the complete history.", "replace_all": false}▴

+30.0s [+0.0s]

tool_call

+30.0s [+0.0s]

tool_result

tool_result: [ok]

+30.0s [+0.0s]

tool_result

tool_result: [ok]

+34.0s [+4.0s]

tool_call

tool_call: Edit {"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "Read-model denormal…{"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "Read-model denormalization optimizes query performance by pre-computing flattened projections. e.g. an OrderSummary projection might join data from OrderPlaced, ItemAdded and PaymentReceived events into a single document.", "new_string": "Read-model denormalization optimizes query performance by pre-computing flattened projections. For example, an OrderSummary projection might join data from OrderPlaced, ItemAdded, and PaymentReceived events into a single document.", "replace_all": false}▴

+34.0s [+0.0s]

tool_call

+34.0s [+0.0s]

tool_result

tool_result: [ok]

+34.0s [+0.0s]

tool_result

tool_result: [ok]

+37.0s [+3.0s]

tool_call

tool_call: Edit {"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "Event throughput me…{"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md", "old_string": "Event throughput metrics alone provide a incomplete picture", "new_string": "Event throughput metrics alone provide an incomplete picture", "replace_all": false}▴

+37.0s [+0.0s]

tool_call

+37.0s [+0.0s]

tool_result

tool_result: [ok]

+37.0s [+0.0s]

tool_result

tool_result: [ok]

+40.0s [+3.0s]

tool_call

tool_call: Read {"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md"}

+40.0s [+0.0s]

tool_call

tool_call: Read {"file_path": "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_preserves_vocabula0/project/draft.md"}

+40.0s [+0.0s]

tool_result

tool_result: [ok]

+40.0s [+0.0s]

tool_result

tool_result: [ok]

Project Files

.claude/
- skills/
  - agent-optimize/
    - SKILL.md
  - dev-record/
  - flesh-out/
    - SKILL.md
    - responsibilities.md
  - review-skill/
    - SKILL.md
    - responsibilities.md
  - review-steps/
    - SKILL.md
    - responsibilities.md
  - sdlc-cross-review/
    - SKILL.md
  - strong-edit/
    - SKILL.md
    - responsibilities.md
- settings.json
audit/
.gitignore
CLAUDE.md
draft.md

Aggregate Statistics

Total Events

Tool Successes

Tool Failures

Sessions

Total Turns

Input Tokens

Output Tokens

2,092

Cache Read

91,149

Cache Created

5,131

Total Cost

$0.1300

Total Duration

48s

API Time

48s

Tool	Calls
Edit	8
Read	4
Bash	4

Tool

Calls

Edit

Read

Bash

Metric	Value
mode	preserve
verdict	CLEAN
coverage	1.0
mean_lexical_overlap	0.9983
mean_ablation_risk	0.0017
mean_semantic_similarity	0.9988
mean_freq_shift	-129.6
concepts	14 in / 14 out / 0 unmatched

Metric

Value

mode

preserve

verdict

CLEAN

coverage

1.0

mean_lexical_overlap

0.9983

mean_ablation_risk

0.0017

mean_semantic_similarity

0.9988

mean_freq_shift

-129.6

concepts

14 in / 14 out / 0 unmatched

Review-Steps Ablation Test

Session Summary

Session Details

Session 1: 3aaf5d04-1b8

Project Files

Aggregate Statistics

Tool Usage Breakdown

Ablation