review-skill / review_skill

Skill under test: .claude/skills/review-skill

Generated: 2026-03-25 22:36:23 UTC | Model: claude-sonnet-4-6 | Sessions: 1

Session Summary

# Session ID Started Ended Tools Rejected Prompts Plans Reports Turns In Tokens Out Tokens Cost Duration
1 0dd14de1-f16 2026-03-25T22:33:16Z 2026-03-25T22:36:23Z 30 0 18 0 0 9 8 4,387 $0.1258 88.0s

Session Details

Session 1: 0dd14de1-f16

tools 30rejected 0prompts 18plans 0agent reports 0turns 9in tokens 8out tokens 4,387cache read 86,952cost $0.1258duration 88.0sapi time 87.6s

started 2026-03-25T22:33:16Z

#TimeTypeDetail show 30 ok results
1 +0.0s [+0.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: /review-skill flawed-skill Complete all review stages (0 through 5). Report fin…/review-skill flawed-skill Complete all review stages (0 through 5). Report findings for every stage, then provide the final summary.▴
2 +0.0s [+0.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: /review-skill flawed-skill Complete all review stages (0 through 5). Report fin…/review-skill flawed-skill Complete all review stages (0 through 5). Report findings for every stage, then provide the final summary.▴
3 +4.0s [+4.0s] tool_call Bash
  • command: "find /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/.claude/skills/flawed-skill -type f 2>/dev/null || echo "Directory not found""
  • description: "List files in flawed-skill directory"
4 +4.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Bash
  • command: "find /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/.claude/skills/flawed-skill -type f 2>/dev/null || echo "Directory not found""
  • description: "List files in flawed-skill directory"
5 +4.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
6 +4.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
7 +4.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Bash
  • command: "ls /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/.claude/skills/ 2>/dev/null"
  • description: "List all skills in the skills directory"
8 +4.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Bash
  • command: "ls /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/.claude/skills/ 2>/dev/null"
  • description: "List all skills in the skills directory"
9 +4.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
10 +4.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
11 +7.0s [+3.0s] tool_call Bash
  • command: "find /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project -name "*.md" | head -30"
  • description: "Find all markdown files in the project"
12 +7.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Bash
  • command: "find /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project -name "*.md" | head -30"
  • description: "Find all markdown files in the project"
13 +7.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
14 +7.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
15 +9.0s [+2.0s] tool_call Read
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/SKILL.md"
16 +9.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Read
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/SKILL.md"
17 +9.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
18 +9.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
19 +10.0s [+1.0s] tool_call Read
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/unused-reference.md"
20 +10.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Read
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/unused-reference.md"
21 +10.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
22 +10.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
23 +17.0s [+7.0s] tool_call Bash
  • command: ls /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/audit/ 2>/dev/null && cat /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/audit/agent-report.sh 2>/dev/null || echo "audit di…ls /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/audit/ 2>/dev/null && cat /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/audit/agent-report.sh 2>/dev/null || echo "audit dir not found"▴
  • description: "Check audit directory and agent-report script"
24 +17.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Bash
  • command: ls /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/audit/ 2>/dev/null && cat /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/audit/agent-report.sh 2>/dev/null || echo "audit di…ls /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/audit/ 2>/dev/null && cat /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/audit/agent-report.sh 2>/dev/null || echo "audit dir not found"▴
  • description: "Check audit directory and agent-report script"
25 +17.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
26 +17.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
27 +21.0s [+4.0s] tool_call Bash
  • command: bash audit/agent-report.sh "review-skill-session-001" "plan_stated" "Review flawed-skill SKILL.md across all 6 stages (0-5): read/understand, frontmatter, prompt structure, effectiveness, alignment, s…bash audit/agent-report.sh "review-skill-session-001" "plan_stated" "Review flawed-skill SKILL.md across all 6 stages (0-5): read/understand, frontmatter, prompt structure, effectiveness, alignment, summary"▴
  • description: "Log plan_stated before starting review"
28 +21.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Bash
  • command: bash audit/agent-report.sh "review-skill-session-001" "plan_stated" "Review flawed-skill SKILL.md across all 6 stages (0-5): read/understand, frontmatter, prompt structure, effectiveness, alignment, s…bash audit/agent-report.sh "review-skill-session-001" "plan_stated" "Review flawed-skill SKILL.md across all 6 stages (0-5): read/understand, frontmatter, prompt structure, effectiveness, alignment, summary"▴
  • description: "Log plan_stated before starting review"
29 +21.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
30 +21.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
31 +62.0s [+41.0s] tool_call Read
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/.claude/skills/review-steps/SKILL.md"
  • limit: 30
32 +63.0s [+1.0s] tool_call Read
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/.claude/skills/review-steps/SKILL.md"
  • limit: 30
33 +63.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
34 +63.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
35 +88.0s [+25.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
36 +88.0s [+0.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
37 +117.0s [+29.0s] tool_call Write
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/SKILL.md"
  • content: --- name: flawed-skill description: Processes and transforms files specified by the user, generating a summary report of changes. Invoke when the user provides files to process and wants structured ou…--- name: flawed-skill description: Processes and transforms files specified by the user, generating a summary report of changes. Invoke when the user provides files to process and wants structured output written to the project directory. allowed-tools: Read, Glob, Grep, Edit, Write, Bash argument-hint: "<file-or-glob> [file-or-glob ...]" --- If `$ARGUMENTS` is empty, ask the user to provide at least one file path or glob before proceeding. If any specified file does not exist or cannot be read, report the issue clearly and stop — do not attempt to proceed with missing inputs. > **Note**: The agent handles file reading, transformation, and report generation. The developer holds final authority on whether output is correct and where files should be written. > > See `responsibilities.md` for the full agent/developer ownership matrix. > See `unused-reference.md` for style guidelines on output format. **Stop after each stage and await confirmation before continuing.** 0. **Understand inputs** (confirm with user) - What files are specified in `$ARGUMENTS`? Are all paths valid? - What kind of transformation does the user want applied? - Where should output files be written? - Confirm scope with the user before making any changes. 1. **Gather inputs** (agent leads, developer confirms) - Read the files specified by `$ARGUMENTS` - Parse contents and identify key sections - Report findings to the user — surface any files that are missing or unreadable before proceeding 2. **Process and transform** (agent leads, developer approves) - Apply the transformations agreed in Stage 0 following the style guidelines in `unused-reference.md` - Generate a summary of changes made - Write output files to the agreed location and note the path to the user 3. **Final report** (agent leads) - Print a markdown summary of what was done - List any warnings or skipped files ## When to use this vs other skills | Goal | Use | |------|-----| | Polish an existing document | **review-steps** | | Critique a document's substance | **strong-edit** | | Process and transform arbitrary files | **flawed-skill** | ▴
38 +117.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Write
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/SKILL.md"
  • content: --- name: flawed-skill description: Processes and transforms files specified by the user, generating a summary report of changes. Invoke when the user provides files to process and wants structured ou…--- name: flawed-skill description: Processes and transforms files specified by the user, generating a summary report of changes. Invoke when the user provides files to process and wants structured output written to the project directory. allowed-tools: Read, Glob, Grep, Edit, Write, Bash argument-hint: "<file-or-glob> [file-or-glob ...]" --- If `$ARGUMENTS` is empty, ask the user to provide at least one file path or glob before proceeding. If any specified file does not exist or cannot be read, report the issue clearly and stop — do not attempt to proceed with missing inputs. > **Note**: The agent handles file reading, transformation, and report generation. The developer holds final authority on whether output is correct and where files should be written. > > See `responsibilities.md` for the full agent/developer ownership matrix. > See `unused-reference.md` for style guidelines on output format. **Stop after each stage and await confirmation before continuing.** 0. **Understand inputs** (confirm with user) - What files are specified in `$ARGUMENTS`? Are all paths valid? - What kind of transformation does the user want applied? - Where should output files be written? - Confirm scope with the user before making any changes. 1. **Gather inputs** (agent leads, developer confirms) - Read the files specified by `$ARGUMENTS` - Parse contents and identify key sections - Report findings to the user — surface any files that are missing or unreadable before proceeding 2. **Process and transform** (agent leads, developer approves) - Apply the transformations agreed in Stage 0 following the style guidelines in `unused-reference.md` - Generate a summary of changes made - Write output files to the agreed location and note the path to the user 3. **Final report** (agent leads) - Print a markdown summary of what was done - List any warnings or skipped files ## When to use this vs other skills | Goal | Use | |------|-----| | Polish an existing document | **review-steps** | | Critique a document's substance | **strong-edit** | | Process and transform arbitrary files | **flawed-skill** | ▴
39 +117.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
40 +117.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
41 +121.0s [+4.0s] tool_call Write
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/responsibilities.md"
  • content: # Responsibilities Ownership matrix for the `flawed-skill` workflow. | Stage | Activity | Agent | Developer | |-------|----------|-------|-----------| | 0 | Identify input files and confirm scope | …# Responsibilities Ownership matrix for the `flawed-skill` workflow. | Stage | Activity | Agent | Developer | |-------|----------|-------|-----------| | 0 | Identify input files and confirm scope | Surfaces file list and asks clarifying questions | Confirms files, transformation type, and output location | | 1 | Read and parse files | Reads files, reports findings | Reviews findings, approves before transformation begins | | 2 | Apply transformations and write output | Applies transformations, writes files, summarises changes | Reviews output, approves or requests revision | | 3 | Final report | Generates markdown summary | Reviews report, flags any missed items | **Agent owns**: file reading, transformation execution, output writing, report generation. **Developer owns**: transformation intent, output location approval, final acceptance of written files. ▴
42 +121.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Write
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/responsibilities.md"
  • content: # Responsibilities Ownership matrix for the `flawed-skill` workflow. | Stage | Activity | Agent | Developer | |-------|----------|-------|-----------| | 0 | Identify input files and confirm scope | …# Responsibilities Ownership matrix for the `flawed-skill` workflow. | Stage | Activity | Agent | Developer | |-------|----------|-------|-----------| | 0 | Identify input files and confirm scope | Surfaces file list and asks clarifying questions | Confirms files, transformation type, and output location | | 1 | Read and parse files | Reads files, reports findings | Reviews findings, approves before transformation begins | | 2 | Apply transformations and write output | Applies transformations, writes files, summarises changes | Reviews output, approves or requests revision | | 3 | Final report | Generates markdown summary | Reviews report, flags any missed items | **Agent owns**: file reading, transformation execution, output writing, report generation. **Developer owns**: transformation intent, output location approval, final acceptance of written files. ▴
43 +121.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
44 +121.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
45 +123.0s [+2.0s] tool_call Read
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/SKILL.md"
46 +123.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Read
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/SKILL.md"
47 +123.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
48 +123.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
49 +132.0s [+9.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
50 +132.0s [+0.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
51 +143.0s [+11.0s] tool_call Bash
  • command: "cp -r /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/.claude/skills/flawed-skill"
  • description: "Copy flawed-skill into the .claude/skills library directory"
52 +143.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Bash
  • command: "cp -r /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/.claude/skills/flawed-skill"
  • description: "Copy flawed-skill into the .claude/skills library directory"
53 +143.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
54 +143.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
55 +145.0s [+2.0s] tool_call Bash
  • command: "ls /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/.claude/skills/flawed-skill/"
  • description: "Verify skill files are in place"
56 +145.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Bash
  • command: "ls /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/.claude/skills/flawed-skill/"
  • description: "Verify skill files are in place"
57 +145.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
58 +145.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
59 +151.0s [+6.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
60 +151.0s [+0.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
61 +158.0s [+7.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
62 +158.0s [+0.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
63 +163.0s [+5.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
64 +163.0s [+0.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
65 +168.0s [+5.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
66 +168.0s [+0.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
67 +171.0s [+3.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
68 +171.0s [+0.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
69 +178.0s [+7.0s] tool_call Bash
  • command: "rm -rf /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill"
  • description: "Remove original draft directory now that skill is published to .claude/skills/"
70 +178.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Bash
  • command: "rm -rf /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill"
  • description: "Remove original draft directory now that skill is published to .claude/skills/"
71 +178.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
72 +178.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
73 +182.0s [+4.0s] tool_call Bash
  • command: "ls /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/"
  • description: "Verify original draft directory is gone"
74 +182.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Bash
  • command: "ls /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/"
  • description: "Verify original draft directory is gone"
75 +182.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
76 +182.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
77 +184.0s [+2.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
78 +184.0s [+0.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
checkPASS no error
checkPASS response length > 100 — 15502 chars

Test Checks

CheckDetail
PASS[Verification] seeded issue: name-kebab
PASS[Verification] seeded issue: description-vague
PASS[Verification] seeded issue: argument-hint-missing
PASS[Verification] seeded issue: stop-after-stage
PASS[Verification] seeded issue: no-stage-0
PASS[Verification] seeded issue: unreferenced-file
PASS[Verification] >= 4 of 6 seeded issues foundfound 6/6: name-kebab, description-vague, argument-hint-missing, stop-after-stage, no-stage-0, unreferenced-file

Project Files

31 file(s) in project (excluding .git, __pycache__):

Aggregate Statistics

Total Events
78
Tool Successes
30
Tool Failures
0
Sessions
1
Total Turns
9
Input Tokens
8
Output Tokens
4,387
Cache Read
86,952
Cache Created
9,025
Total Cost
$0.1258
Total Duration
88s
API Time
88s

Tool Usage Breakdown

ToolCalls
Bash18
Read8
Write4