| # | Time | Type | Detail show 32 ok results |
|---|
| 1 |
+0.0s [+0.0s] |
user_prompt |
user_prompt: /review-skill flawed-skill
Complete all review stages (0 through 5).
Report fin…/review-skill flawed-skill
Complete all review stages (0 through 5).
Report findings for every stage, then provide the final summary.▴ |
| 2 |
+0.0s [+0.0s] |
user_prompt |
user_prompt: /review-skill flawed-skill
Complete all review stages (0 through 5).
Report fin…/review-skill flawed-skill
Complete all review stages (0 through 5).
Report findings for every stage, then provide the final summary.▴ |
| 3 |
+6.0s [+6.0s] |
tool_call |
Bash - command: "ls -la /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/.claude/skills/flawed-skill/"
- description: "List files in flawed-skill directory"
|
| 4 |
+6.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_call |
Bash - command: "ls -la /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/.claude/skills/flawed-skill/"
- description: "List files in flawed-skill directory"
|
| 5 |
+11.0s [+5.0s] |
tool_call |
Bash - command: "ls -la /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/.claude/skills/"
- description: "List all skills in the repo"
|
| 6 |
+11.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_call |
Bash - command: "ls -la /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/.claude/skills/"
- description: "List all skills in the repo"
|
| 7 |
+11.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 8 |
+11.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 9 |
+14.0s [+3.0s] |
tool_call |
Glob - pattern: "**/flawed-skill/**"
- path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project"
|
| 10 |
+14.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_call |
Glob - pattern: "**/flawed-skill/**"
- path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project"
|
| 11 |
+14.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 12 |
+14.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 13 |
+14.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_call |
Glob - pattern: "**/flawed*"
- path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project"
|
| 14 |
+14.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_call |
Glob - pattern: "**/flawed*"
- path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project"
|
| 15 |
+14.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 16 |
+14.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 17 |
+17.0s [+3.0s] |
tool_call |
Read - file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/SKILL.md"
|
| 18 |
+17.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_call |
Read - file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/SKILL.md"
|
| 19 |
+17.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 20 |
+17.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 21 |
+17.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_call |
Read - file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/unused-reference.md"
|
| 22 |
+17.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_call |
Read - file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/unused-reference.md"
|
| 23 |
+17.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 24 |
+17.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 25 |
+65.0s [+48.0s] |
user_prompt |
user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested. |
| 26 |
+65.0s [+0.0s] |
user_prompt |
user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested. |
| 27 |
+73.0s [+8.0s] |
tool_call |
Bash - command: bash /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/audit/agent-report.sh "review-session" "plan_stated" "Rework flawed-skill: fix frontmatter (name, description, argument-hint), add Stag…bash /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/audit/agent-report.sh "review-session" "plan_stated" "Rework flawed-skill: fix frontmatter (name, description, argument-hint), add Stage 0 and pause instructions, add argument validation, reference unused-reference.md, add when-to-use section, create responsibilities.md"▴
- description: "Log plan_stated event"
|
| 28 |
+73.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_call |
Bash - command: bash /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/audit/agent-report.sh "review-session" "plan_stated" "Rework flawed-skill: fix frontmatter (name, description, argument-hint), add Stag…bash /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/audit/agent-report.sh "review-session" "plan_stated" "Rework flawed-skill: fix frontmatter (name, description, argument-hint), add Stage 0 and pause instructions, add argument validation, reference unused-reference.md, add when-to-use section, create responsibilities.md"▴
- description: "Log plan_stated event"
|
| 29 |
+73.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 30 |
+73.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 31 |
+92.0s [+19.0s] |
tool_call |
Write - file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/SKILL.md"
- content: ---
name: flawed-skill
description: Processes source files by extracting key sections, applying structured transformations, and writing output files. Use when you need to batch-transform files accordi…---
name: flawed-skill
description: Processes source files by extracting key sections, applying structured transformations, and writing output files. Use when you need to batch-transform files according to a style guide and produce a change summary.
allowed-tools: Read, Glob, Grep, Edit, Write, Bash
argument-hint: <file-or-glob-pattern>
---
> **Note**: The agent drives each stage but pauses for developer confirmation before proceeding. See `responsibilities.md` for the ownership matrix.
**Stop after each stage and have changes reviewed with the user.**
0. **Understand the task** (agent proposes, developer confirms)
- What files does `$ARGUMENTS` resolve to? List them.
- If `$ARGUMENTS` is empty or invalid, ask the user which files to process and stop here.
- Summarize: how many files, what type, estimated scope of work.
- Confirm understanding with the developer before proceeding.
1. **Gather inputs**
- Read the files specified by `$ARGUMENTS`.
- For each file, identify sections by heading structure and content boundaries.
- Report what was found: number of files read, sections identified, any files that could not be read (with reasons).
- Apply the formatting conventions from `unused-reference.md` as the style baseline.
2. **Process and transform**
- Apply transformations to extracted sections:
- Normalize heading levels to a consistent hierarchy.
- Reformat bullet lists and paragraphs per the style guide in `unused-reference.md`.
- Flag sections that need manual review (ambiguous structure, mixed formats).
- Present a preview of proposed changes to the developer before writing any files.
- After approval, write output files to the project directory using the pattern `<original-name>.transformed.md`.
3. **Final report**
- Print a summary: files processed, sections transformed, output file paths.
- List any warnings encountered (unreadable files, skipped sections, style conflicts).
- Ask the developer if any outputs need revision.
## When to Use This vs Other Skills
| Goal | Use |
|------|-----|
| Batch-transform files by a style guide | **flawed-skill** |
| Review a document for language polish | **review-steps** |
| Substantive editorial critique of an article | **strong-edit** |
| Expand a skeleton draft into structured content | **flesh-out** |
▴
|
| 32 |
+92.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_call |
Write - file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/SKILL.md"
- content: ---
name: flawed-skill
description: Processes source files by extracting key sections, applying structured transformations, and writing output files. Use when you need to batch-transform files accordi…---
name: flawed-skill
description: Processes source files by extracting key sections, applying structured transformations, and writing output files. Use when you need to batch-transform files according to a style guide and produce a change summary.
allowed-tools: Read, Glob, Grep, Edit, Write, Bash
argument-hint: <file-or-glob-pattern>
---
> **Note**: The agent drives each stage but pauses for developer confirmation before proceeding. See `responsibilities.md` for the ownership matrix.
**Stop after each stage and have changes reviewed with the user.**
0. **Understand the task** (agent proposes, developer confirms)
- What files does `$ARGUMENTS` resolve to? List them.
- If `$ARGUMENTS` is empty or invalid, ask the user which files to process and stop here.
- Summarize: how many files, what type, estimated scope of work.
- Confirm understanding with the developer before proceeding.
1. **Gather inputs**
- Read the files specified by `$ARGUMENTS`.
- For each file, identify sections by heading structure and content boundaries.
- Report what was found: number of files read, sections identified, any files that could not be read (with reasons).
- Apply the formatting conventions from `unused-reference.md` as the style baseline.
2. **Process and transform**
- Apply transformations to extracted sections:
- Normalize heading levels to a consistent hierarchy.
- Reformat bullet lists and paragraphs per the style guide in `unused-reference.md`.
- Flag sections that need manual review (ambiguous structure, mixed formats).
- Present a preview of proposed changes to the developer before writing any files.
- After approval, write output files to the project directory using the pattern `<original-name>.transformed.md`.
3. **Final report**
- Print a summary: files processed, sections transformed, output file paths.
- List any warnings encountered (unreadable files, skipped sections, style conflicts).
- Ask the developer if any outputs need revision.
## When to Use This vs Other Skills
| Goal | Use |
|------|-----|
| Batch-transform files by a style guide | **flawed-skill** |
| Review a document for language polish | **review-steps** |
| Substantive editorial critique of an article | **strong-edit** |
| Expand a skeleton draft into structured content | **flesh-out** |
▴
|
| 33 |
+92.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 34 |
+92.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 35 |
+95.0s [+3.0s] |
tool_call |
Write - file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/responsibilities.md"
- content: # Responsibilities — flawed-skill
| Stage | Agent | Developer |
|-------|-------|-----------|
| 0. Understand the task | Lists resolved files, summarizes scope | Confirms file list and scope are corr…# Responsibilities — flawed-skill
| Stage | Agent | Developer |
|-------|-------|-----------|
| 0. Understand the task | Lists resolved files, summarizes scope | Confirms file list and scope are correct |
| 1. Gather inputs | Reads files, identifies sections, reports findings | Reviews section breakdown, flags corrections |
| 2. Process and transform | Applies transformations, presents preview | Approves preview before files are written |
| 3. Final report | Prints summary and warnings | Decides if outputs need revision |
**Ownership principle**: The agent never writes output files without explicit developer approval.
▴
|
| 36 |
+95.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_call |
Write - file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/responsibilities.md"
- content: # Responsibilities — flawed-skill
| Stage | Agent | Developer |
|-------|-------|-----------|
| 0. Understand the task | Lists resolved files, summarizes scope | Confirms file list and scope are corr…# Responsibilities — flawed-skill
| Stage | Agent | Developer |
|-------|-------|-----------|
| 0. Understand the task | Lists resolved files, summarizes scope | Confirms file list and scope are correct |
| 1. Gather inputs | Reads files, identifies sections, reports findings | Reviews section breakdown, flags corrections |
| 2. Process and transform | Applies transformations, presents preview | Approves preview before files are written |
| 3. Final report | Prints summary and warnings | Decides if outputs need revision |
**Ownership principle**: The agent never writes output files without explicit developer approval.
▴
|
| 37 |
+95.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 38 |
+95.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 39 |
+100.0s [+5.0s] |
tool_call |
Bash - command: bash /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/audit/agent-report.sh "review-session" "scope_creep" "Created responsibilities.md — not explicitly in the original skill but recommende…bash /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/audit/agent-report.sh "review-session" "scope_creep" "Created responsibilities.md — not explicitly in the original skill but recommended by the review and approved by user"▴
- description: "Log scope_creep for new file"
|
| 40 |
+100.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_call |
Bash - command: bash /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/audit/agent-report.sh "review-session" "scope_creep" "Created responsibilities.md — not explicitly in the original skill but recommende…bash /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/audit/agent-report.sh "review-session" "scope_creep" "Created responsibilities.md — not explicitly in the original skill but recommended by the review and approved by user"▴
- description: "Log scope_creep for new file"
|
| 41 |
+100.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 42 |
+100.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 43 |
+112.0s [+12.0s] |
user_prompt |
user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested. |
| 44 |
+112.0s [+0.0s] |
user_prompt |
user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested. |
| 45 |
+115.0s [+3.0s] |
tool_call |
Bash - command: "ls -la /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/"
- description: "List files in flawed-skill directory"
|
| 46 |
+115.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_call |
Bash - command: "ls -la /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/"
- description: "List files in flawed-skill directory"
|
| 47 |
+115.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 48 |
+115.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 49 |
+118.0s [+3.0s] |
tool_call |
Read - file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/SKILL.md"
|
| 50 |
+118.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_call |
Read - file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/SKILL.md"
|
| 51 |
+118.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 52 |
+118.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 53 |
+118.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_call |
Read - file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/responsibilities.md"
|
| 54 |
+118.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_call |
Read - file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/responsibilities.md"
|
| 55 |
+118.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 56 |
+118.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 57 |
+125.0s [+7.0s] |
user_prompt |
user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested. |
| 58 |
+125.0s [+0.0s] |
user_prompt |
user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested. |
| 59 |
+131.0s [+6.0s] |
user_prompt |
user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested. |
| 60 |
+131.0s [+0.0s] |
user_prompt |
user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested. |
| 61 |
+134.0s [+3.0s] |
user_prompt |
user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested. |
| 62 |
+134.0s [+0.0s] |
user_prompt |
user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested. |
| 63 |
+139.0s [+5.0s] |
tool_call |
Bash - command: "git status"
- description: "Show working tree status"
|
| 64 |
+139.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_call |
Bash - command: "git status"
- description: "Show working tree status"
|
| 65 |
+139.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 66 |
+139.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 67 |
+139.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_call |
Bash - command: "git diff"
- description: "Show staged and unstaged changes"
|
| 68 |
+139.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_call |
Bash - command: "git diff"
- description: "Show staged and unstaged changes"
|
| 69 |
+139.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 70 |
+139.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 71 |
+140.0s [+1.0s] |
tool_call |
Bash - command: "git log --oneline -5"
- description: "Show recent commits"
|
| 72 |
+140.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_call |
Bash - command: "git log --oneline -5"
- description: "Show recent commits"
|
| 73 |
+140.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 74 |
+140.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 75 |
+147.0s [+7.0s] |
tool_call |
Bash - command: git add flawed-skill/SKILL.md flawed-skill/responsibilities.md flawed-skill/unused-reference.md && git commit -m "$(cat <<'EOF'
Fix flawed-skill: rework frontmatter, structure, and alignment
Addresse…git add flawed-skill/SKILL.md flawed-skill/responsibilities.md flawed-skill/unused-reference.md && git commit -m "$(cat <<'EOF'
Fix flawed-skill: rework frontmatter, structure, and alignment
Addresses all issues found during skill review:
- Fix name to kebab-case matching directory
- Replace vague description with specific trigger context
- Add argument-hint, Stage 0, pause instructions, argument validation
- Reference unused-reference.md as style baseline
- Add responsibilities.md and when-to-use comparison table
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
EOF
)" && git status▴
- description: "Stage flawed-skill files and commit"
|
| 76 |
+147.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_call |
Bash - command: git add flawed-skill/SKILL.md flawed-skill/responsibilities.md flawed-skill/unused-reference.md && git commit -m "$(cat <<'EOF'
Fix flawed-skill: rework frontmatter, structure, and alignment
Addresse…git add flawed-skill/SKILL.md flawed-skill/responsibilities.md flawed-skill/unused-reference.md && git commit -m "$(cat <<'EOF'
Fix flawed-skill: rework frontmatter, structure, and alignment
Addresses all issues found during skill review:
- Fix name to kebab-case matching directory
- Replace vague description with specific trigger context
- Add argument-hint, Stage 0, pause instructions, argument validation
- Reference unused-reference.md as style baseline
- Add responsibilities.md and when-to-use comparison table
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
EOF
)" && git status▴
- description: "Stage flawed-skill files and commit"
|
| 77 |
+147.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 78 |
+147.0s [+0.0s] |
tool_result |
PASS |
| 79 |
+152.0s [+5.0s] |
user_prompt |
user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested. |
| 80 |
+152.0s [+0.0s] |
user_prompt |
user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested. |
| 81 |
+155.0s [+3.0s] |
user_prompt |
user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested. |
| 82 |
+155.0s [+0.0s] |
user_prompt |
user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested. |
| 83 |
+159.0s [+4.0s] |
user_prompt |
user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested. |
| 84 |
+159.0s [+0.0s] |
user_prompt |
user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested. |
| | check | PASS no error |
| | check | PASS response length > 100 — 12469 chars |