review-skill / test_review_finds_seeded_issues

Skill under test: .claude/skills/review-skill
Invoke review-skill on a flawed fixture and verify seeded issues are found.

Generated: 2026-04-03 11:19:38 UTC | Model: claude-sonnet-4-6 | Sessions: 1

Hard: PASS (4/4) Achievement: 100.0%

Session Summary

# Session ID Started Ended Tools Rejected Prompts Plans Reports Turns In Tokens Out Tokens Cost Duration
1 ab2c1924-eb2 2026-04-03T11:16:06Z 2026-04-03T11:19:38Z 20 0 18 0 1 7 6 4,482 $0.1222 83.2s

Session Details

Session 1: ab2c1924-eb2

tools 20rejected 0prompts 18plans 0agent reports 1turns 7in tokens 6out tokens 4,482cache read 58,153cost $0.1222duration 83.2sapi time 83.0s

started 2026-04-03T11:16:06Z

#TimeTypeDetail show 20 ok results
1 +0.0s [+0.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: /review-skill flawed-skill Complete all review stages (0 through 5). Report fin…/review-skill flawed-skill Complete all review stages (0 through 5). Report findings for every stage, then provide the final summary.▴
2 +0.0s [+0.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: /review-skill flawed-skill Complete all review stages (0 through 5). Report fin…/review-skill flawed-skill Complete all review stages (0 through 5). Report findings for every stage, then provide the final summary.▴
3 +3.0s [+3.0s] tool_call Glob
  • pattern: "**/*"
  • path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/.claude/skills"
4 +3.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Glob
  • pattern: "**/*"
  • path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/.claude/skills"
5 +3.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
6 +3.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
7 +5.0s [+2.0s] tool_call Glob
  • pattern: "**/*"
  • path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project"
8 +5.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Glob
  • pattern: "**/*"
  • path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project"
9 +5.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
10 +5.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
11 +8.0s [+3.0s] tool_call Read
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/SKILL.md"
12 +8.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Read
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/SKILL.md"
13 +8.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
14 +8.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
15 +8.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Read
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/unused-reference.md"
16 +8.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Read
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/unused-reference.md"
17 +8.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
18 +8.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
19 +12.0s [+4.0s] tool_call Read
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/.claude/skills/review-skill/SKILL.md"
20 +12.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Read
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/.claude/skills/review-skill/SKILL.md"
21 +12.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
22 +12.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
23 +12.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Read
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/.claude/skills/flesh-out/SKILL.md"
24 +12.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Read
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/.claude/skills/flesh-out/SKILL.md"
25 +12.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
26 +12.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
27 +83.0s [+71.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
28 +83.0s [+0.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
29 +92.0s [+9.0s] tool_call Bash
  • command: bash /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/audit/agent-report.sh "ab2c1924-eb20-4c98-bf93-0d91a358d36b" "plan_stated" "Apply all review-skill fixes to flawed-skill: frontmatter, …bash /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/audit/agent-report.sh "ab2c1924-eb20-4c98-bf93-0d91a358d36b" "plan_stated" "Apply all review-skill fixes to flawed-skill: frontmatter, body structure, and create responsibilities.md"▴
  • description: "Log plan_stated before implementing fixes"
30 +92.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Bash
  • command: bash /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/audit/agent-report.sh "ab2c1924-eb20-4c98-bf93-0d91a358d36b" "plan_stated" "Apply all review-skill fixes to flawed-skill: frontmatter, …bash /tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/audit/agent-report.sh "ab2c1924-eb20-4c98-bf93-0d91a358d36b" "plan_stated" "Apply all review-skill fixes to flawed-skill: frontmatter, body structure, and create responsibilities.md"▴
  • description: "Log plan_stated before implementing fixes"
31 +92.0s [+0.0s] agent_report plan_stated Apply all review-skill fixes to flawed-skill: frontmatter, body structure, and c…Apply all review-skill fixes to flawed-skill: frontmatter, body structure, and create responsibilities.md▴
32 +92.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
33 +92.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
34 +104.0s [+12.0s] tool_call Write
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/SKILL.md"
  • content: --- name: flawed-skill description: > Processes files provided as arguments — reads, transforms, and writes output. Use when you need to apply structured transformations to one or more files and…--- name: flawed-skill description: > Processes files provided as arguments — reads, transforms, and writes output. Use when you need to apply structured transformations to one or more files and produce a summary report of what was changed. allowed-tools: Read, Glob, Grep, Edit, Write, Bash argument-hint: <file>... --- This skill processes files provided via `$ARGUMENTS`, applies transformations, and produces output files with a summary report. **Stop after each stage and have changes reviewed with the user.** > **Note**: The agent reads and transforms content, but the developer confirms which files to process and reviews all proposed output before writing. > > See `responsibilities.md` for the full agent/developer ownership matrix. 0. **Confirm inputs** (developer confirms) - If `$ARGUMENTS` is empty, print usage: `Usage: /flawed-skill <file> [<file>...]` and stop. - List the files passed via `$ARGUMENTS` — do they exist and are they readable? - What transformations will be applied to each file? Confirm with the developer before proceeding. 1. **Gather inputs** (agent leads) - Read the files specified by `$ARGUMENTS` - If any file cannot be read, report it as a warning and skip it — do not abort the whole run. - Parse contents and identify key sections - Format all output according to the style guide in `unused-reference.md` 2. **Process and transform** (agent leads with approval) - Apply transformations to extracted sections - Generate a summary of changes made - Propose output file names and contents — write only after developer approval 3. **Final report** (agent leads) - Print a markdown summary of what was done - List any warnings encountered (e.g. skipped files, unrecognised sections) ## When to Use This vs Other Skills | Goal | Use | |------|-----| | Transform files with structured output | **flawed-skill** | | Expand raw document drafts | **flesh-out** | | Polish existing documents | **review-steps** | ▴
35 +104.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Write
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/SKILL.md"
  • content: --- name: flawed-skill description: > Processes files provided as arguments — reads, transforms, and writes output. Use when you need to apply structured transformations to one or more files and…--- name: flawed-skill description: > Processes files provided as arguments — reads, transforms, and writes output. Use when you need to apply structured transformations to one or more files and produce a summary report of what was changed. allowed-tools: Read, Glob, Grep, Edit, Write, Bash argument-hint: <file>... --- This skill processes files provided via `$ARGUMENTS`, applies transformations, and produces output files with a summary report. **Stop after each stage and have changes reviewed with the user.** > **Note**: The agent reads and transforms content, but the developer confirms which files to process and reviews all proposed output before writing. > > See `responsibilities.md` for the full agent/developer ownership matrix. 0. **Confirm inputs** (developer confirms) - If `$ARGUMENTS` is empty, print usage: `Usage: /flawed-skill <file> [<file>...]` and stop. - List the files passed via `$ARGUMENTS` — do they exist and are they readable? - What transformations will be applied to each file? Confirm with the developer before proceeding. 1. **Gather inputs** (agent leads) - Read the files specified by `$ARGUMENTS` - If any file cannot be read, report it as a warning and skip it — do not abort the whole run. - Parse contents and identify key sections - Format all output according to the style guide in `unused-reference.md` 2. **Process and transform** (agent leads with approval) - Apply transformations to extracted sections - Generate a summary of changes made - Propose output file names and contents — write only after developer approval 3. **Final report** (agent leads) - Print a markdown summary of what was done - List any warnings encountered (e.g. skipped files, unrecognised sections) ## When to Use This vs Other Skills | Goal | Use | |------|-----| | Transform files with structured output | **flawed-skill** | | Expand raw document drafts | **flesh-out** | | Polish existing documents | **review-steps** | ▴
36 +104.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
37 +104.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
38 +110.0s [+6.0s] tool_call Write
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/responsibilities.md"
  • content: # Responsibilities — flawed-skill This table defines who owns each decision in the flawed-skill workflow. | Stage | Step | Owner | |-------|------|-------| | 0 | Decide which files to process | **De…# Responsibilities — flawed-skill This table defines who owns each decision in the flawed-skill workflow. | Stage | Step | Owner | |-------|------|-------| | 0 | Decide which files to process | **Developer** | | 0 | Confirm transformations to apply | **Developer** | | 1 | Read and parse file contents | Agent | | 1 | Identify key sections | Agent | | 1 | Report unreadable files as warnings | Agent | | 2 | Propose transformations | Agent | | 2 | Approve output before writing | **Developer** | | 2 | Approve output file names | **Developer** | | 3 | Write final report | Agent | | 3 | Decide whether warnings require follow-up | **Developer** | ▴
39 +110.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Write
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/responsibilities.md"
  • content: # Responsibilities — flawed-skill This table defines who owns each decision in the flawed-skill workflow. | Stage | Step | Owner | |-------|------|-------| | 0 | Decide which files to process | **De…# Responsibilities — flawed-skill This table defines who owns each decision in the flawed-skill workflow. | Stage | Step | Owner | |-------|------|-------| | 0 | Decide which files to process | **Developer** | | 0 | Confirm transformations to apply | **Developer** | | 1 | Read and parse file contents | Agent | | 1 | Identify key sections | Agent | | 1 | Report unreadable files as warnings | Agent | | 2 | Propose transformations | Agent | | 2 | Approve output before writing | **Developer** | | 2 | Approve output file names | **Developer** | | 3 | Write final report | Agent | | 3 | Decide whether warnings require follow-up | **Developer** | ▴
40 +110.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
41 +110.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
42 +113.0s [+3.0s] tool_call Read
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/SKILL.md"
43 +113.0s [+0.0s] tool_call Read
  • file_path: "/tmp/pytest-sandbox/test_review_finds_seeded_issue0/project/flawed-skill/SKILL.md"
44 +113.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
45 +113.0s [+0.0s] tool_result PASS
46 +121.0s [+8.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
47 +121.0s [+0.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
48 +136.0s [+15.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
49 +136.0s [+0.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
50 +147.0s [+11.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
51 +147.0s [+0.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
52 +158.0s [+11.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
53 +158.0s [+0.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
54 +171.0s [+13.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
55 +171.0s [+0.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
56 +189.0s [+18.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
57 +189.0s [+0.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
58 +202.0s [+13.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
59 +202.0s [+0.0s] user_prompt user_prompt: Please proceed as suggested.
requirePASS no error
expectPASS response length >= 100 — 15910 chars
achieveACHIEVED seeded issue: name-kebab [challenging]
achieveACHIEVED seeded issue: description-vague [challenging]
achieveACHIEVED seeded issue: argument-hint-missing [challenging]
achieveACHIEVED seeded issue: stop-after-stage [challenging]
achieveACHIEVED seeded issue: no-stage-0 [challenging]
achieveACHIEVED seeded issue: unreferenced-file [challenging]

Test Checks

KindCheckDetail
PASSrequire[Review] result exists
PASSexpect[Verification] >= 4 of 6 seeded issues foundfound 6/6: name-kebab, description-vague, argument-hint-missing, stop-after-stage, no-stage-0, unreferenced-file

Project Files

36 file(s) in project (excluding .git, __pycache__):

Aggregate Statistics

Total Events
59
Tool Successes
20
Tool Failures
0
Sessions
1
Total Turns
7
Input Tokens
6
Output Tokens
4,482
Cache Read
58,153
Cache Created
9,992
Total Cost
$0.1222
Total Duration
83s
API Time
83s

Tool Usage Breakdown

ToolCalls
Read10
Glob4
Write4
Bash2